1 Child L 1 , Child L 2 and Adult L 2 Acquisition : Differences and Similarities
نویسنده
چکیده
Second language acquisition research often compares non-native acquirers (L2ers) with other learner populations. Such cross-population comparisons include: (i) child native language (L1) acquisition~child L2 acquisition (e.g. Gavruseva 2000; Weerman et al. 2003); (ii) child L2~adult L2 (e.g. Cancino et al. 1978; McDonald 2000; Montrul 2002; Weerman et al. 2003) and (iii) child L1~adult L2 (Cancino et al. 1978; Jordens 1988; Neeleman and Weerman 1997, a.o.). Focussing on the second of these comparisons, this paper presents an analysis of production data from English-speaking child and adult non-native acquirers (L2ers) of Dutch. The specific property of Dutch to be acquired, direct object scrambling over negation, is a phenomenon which instantiates interaction between different modules of language and as such, may be informative with respect to the syntax-semantics interface in L2 acquisition. On the basis of experimental data on the (non-) scrambling of definite DP objects, specific and non-specific indefinite DP objects, two claims are made: (i) English-speaking adult and child L2ers go through the same developmental sequences in their acquisition of direct object scrambling in Dutch, and (ii) non-targetlike scrambling results from missing syntactic knowledge. The outline of this paper is as follows: section 1 explains the rationale behind the adult L2~child L2 comparison. This is followed in section 2 by a brief summary of scrambling over negation. Section 3 presents the subjects, methodology and results of the L2 experiment. In the discsussion in section 4, we consider what the results tell us about L2 acquisition, what they tell us about L2 scrambling and how these results compare to L1 acquisition data.
منابع مشابه
The production of lexical categories (VP) and functional categories (copula) at the initial stage of child L2 acquisition
This is a longitudinal case study of two Farsi-speaking children learning English: ‘Bernard’ and ‘Melissa’, who were 7;4 and 8;4 at the start of data collection. The research deals with the initial state and further development in the child second language (L2) acquisition of syntax regarding the presence or absence of copula as a functional category, as well as the role and degree of L1 influe...
متن کاملA corpus of consonant-vowel-consonant real words and nonwords: comparison of phonotactic probability, neighborhood density, and consonant age of acquisition.
A corpus of 5,765 consonant-vowel-consonant sequences (CVCs) was compiled, and phonotactic probability and neighborhood density were computed for both child and adult corpora. This corpus of CVCs, provided as supplementary materials, was analyzed to address the following questions: (1) Do computations based on a child corpus differ from those based on an adult corpus? (2) Do the phonotactic pro...
متن کاملDescribing the development of intonational categories using a target-oriented parametric approach
In this paper we analyze the relation between adults’ intonational categories as described in the ToBI framework and children’s intonation contours, using a parametric approach and cluster evaluation methods. In the field of prosody, an increasing number of studies on the development of intonation apply the intonational categories of adult speech described as a sequence of high (H) and low (L) ...
متن کاملA longitudinal examination of the parent-child distress relationship in children with juvenile rheumatic disease.
OBJECTIVE To examine the longitudinal relationships between parent and child distress in a sample of children with juvenile rheumatic diseases (JRDs). DESIGN Cross-lagged panel correlation analysis tested the temporal precedence of parent distress versus child distress over a 1-year period. PARTICIPANTS Thirty-seven children (ages 9-17 years; 22 girls) diagnosed with JRD and their parents c...
متن کامل